Skibidi Toilet DMCA: Legitimacy Questioned

Garry Newman, creator of Garry's Mod, reportedly received a DMCA takedown notice concerning unauthorized Skibidi Toilet content within the Garry's Mod platform. The sender's identity remains unclear, despite initial reports implicating Invisible Narratives, the studio behind the Skibidi Toilet film and TV franchises. A Discord profile seemingly belonging to the Skibidi Toilet creator has since denied sending the notice, as reported by Dexerto.

The DMCA Claim: The notice demanded the removal of "unauthorized Skibidi Toilet Garry’s Mod games," citing the absence of any licensed Skibidi Toilet content on Steam, Valve, or within Garry's Mod itself.

The Irony: The situation is particularly ironic, considering the Skibidi Toilet series itself originated from assets within Garry's Mod, utilized by YouTuber Alexey Gerasimov (DaFuq!?Boom!) via Source Filmmaker. This meme-driven series gained immense popularity, leading to merchandise and planned film/TV adaptations.

Counterarguments and Responses:

Newman publicized the DMCA on the s&box Discord server, expressing disbelief. Invisible Narratives' notice asserted copyright ownership over characters like Titan Cameraman, Titan Speakerman, Titan TV Man, and Skibidi Toilet, pointing to DaFuq!?Boom! as the original source. This claim is complicated by the fact that Garry's Mod, while using assets from Valve's Half-Life 2 (with Valve's permission), presents a complex legal landscape. Valve, as the original copyright holder of Half-Life 2 assets, arguably has a stronger claim than Invisible Narratives.

DaFuq!?Boom! subsequently denied involvement in the DMCA on the s&box Discord, expressing confusion and seeking contact with Newman. The notice itself listed "Invisible Narratives, LLC" as the copyright holder, claiming copyright on the aforementioned characters in 2023.

Previous Copyright Disputes: This isn't DaFuq!?Boom!'s first copyright controversy. Last September, they issued multiple copyright strikes against GameToons, a similar YouTuber, eventually reaching a settlement after escalating tensions.

Conclusion: The legitimacy of the DMCA notice remains uncertain. The situation highlights the complexities of copyright in the digital age, particularly concerning derivative works and the use of user-generated content. The origin of the notice, and its implications for the future of Skibidi Toilet content creation, remain to be seen.